Who is going home tonight? Let's keep it quick and simple. Sofa means they're safe and Stool means they're in the Bottom 3.
Chikezie Eze - Stool
Brooke White – Sofa
Carly Smithson – through my many votes - she gets a seat on the Sofa
David Archuleta – Sofa
David Cook – Sofa
Syesha Mercado – Stool
Michael Johns – Sofa
Ramielle Malubay –Sofa
Kristy Lee Cook – Sofa
Jason Castro – Stool
This Bottom 3 does not surprise me - although I'd rather see Ramielle in the bunch. Jason is the first to learn he is safe. Syesha is safe and it's Chikezie going home.
Wednesday, March 26, 2008
Tuesday, March 25, 2008
David Cook Declared 2008 American Idol
First of all, why in the world was Carly Smithson in the Bottom 3 last week? There's no sense in that kind of bull dooky. I'll do my part to make sure that doesn't happen this week - unless she totally stinks it up. This week our Top Ten will perform a hit song from their year of birth. Yawn.
Ramiele Malubay
1987/Heart/"Alone"
You have to have Amanda Overmeyr type vocals to pull a song like this off. But, alas, Amanda is gone. Some of the notes fall flat for Ramiele but I give her credit for giving it her all. Unfortunately, that means screaming through the "Alone" part of "Alone." Will she fall victim to being the first to perform tonight or will she fall victim to poor song choice? Either way, I'm certain she'll be in the Bottom 3 tomorrow night unless the other nine screw it all up tonight.
Jason Castro
1987/Sting/"How Fragile We Are"
He's celebrating his 21st birthday today. Even though this song is from the year I graduated high school, I don't recognize it all. Still, Jason's voice is beautifully fluid and he won't be going anywhere any time soon - unless this peculiar song choice hurts him.
Syesha Mercado
1987/Stephanie Mills/"If I Were Your Woman"
I started my first job in radio in 1987 - it was an Adult/Top 40 station and I don't ever remember playing this song or that Sting diddy that Jason just performed. Okay, maybe I remember this one a little. I guess she sang it okay. It just didn't do much for me.
Chikezie Eze
1985/Luther Vandross/"If Only for One Night"
Chikezie delivers a solid performance but I'd like to see Chikezie sing like Chikezie and not necessarily like Luther. He didn't make it his own and that could hurt him. Randy seems to agree with me.
Brooke White
1983/Police/"Every Breath You Take"
Starts out rough so she starts over. I've never been able to learn all the words to this song. She's got those down pat but she seems a little flat on the chorus. It's hard to say how this will be received. Definitely not her best. Still, better than most ... and definitely prettier than most. Who else could make such a big mistake in the beginning and still be forgiven by the judges?
Michael Johns
1978/Queen/"We Are the Champions"
He does Queen very well. Not as nice as when he did "Bohemian Rhapsody," but still quite enjoyable. Finally, some good music for my ears tonight. Can I say he has a nice butt? Well, it is my blog reflecting no connection with anything but myself so ... NICE BUTT! Oh, he sang very well too!
Carly Smithson
1983/Bonnie Tyler/"Total Eclipse of the Heart"
BIG BIG SONG CHOICE ALERT! I remember the first time I ever heard this song and I proclaimed it would go to Number 1 in a big hurry. One of my many song predictions to come true. For Carly - EXCELLENT song choice. Randy didn't like it and therefore should be tested for drug use. I must agree with Paula that Carly could do no wrong. Why are they trying to push her out of the competition? I'm so giving all my votes to her and Michael Johns so far!
David Archuleta
1990/David Foster/"You're the Voice"
While it's not his best performance, David is totally feeling this song and looks like he's having a blast performing it. Not my kind of song, whatever song it is, but how can you not love Archuleta?
Kristy Lee Cook
1984/Lee Greenwood/"God Bless the USA"
Smart move going with a country song. But will she properly emote it? If it were the 4th of July, I'd be waving the flag. As it is, she misses a few notes and pitchiness. I have no idea how she will fare this week. Simon loves it and even comments on the smartness of the song choice - seeing as it this is "AMERICAN" Idol!
David Cook
1982/Michael Jackson/"Billie Jean"
He's singing some other's rendition of Michael Jackson's "Billie Jean." I'm not crazy about the version but I'm definitely crazy about David Cook. This dude has the vocals, dude, and like, dude, he stands a great chance of being in the Top 3 and potentially our next American Idol. Randy has proclaimed him the winner. Paula is so damned impressed that she stands to deliver her words of actual wisdom. Simon called it brave and amazing. Now we know why he got the "pimp" spot. Crap - now I have to vote for three people. I better get busy!
My picks for Bottom 3 tonight are: Ramiele, Syesha and Chikezie. Who is going home? Probably Kristy Lee - but she doesn't deserve it.
Kimberley Locke performs tomorrow night! Hooray!
Ramiele Malubay
1987/Heart/"Alone"
You have to have Amanda Overmeyr type vocals to pull a song like this off. But, alas, Amanda is gone. Some of the notes fall flat for Ramiele but I give her credit for giving it her all. Unfortunately, that means screaming through the "Alone" part of "Alone." Will she fall victim to being the first to perform tonight or will she fall victim to poor song choice? Either way, I'm certain she'll be in the Bottom 3 tomorrow night unless the other nine screw it all up tonight.
Jason Castro
1987/Sting/"How Fragile We Are"
He's celebrating his 21st birthday today. Even though this song is from the year I graduated high school, I don't recognize it all. Still, Jason's voice is beautifully fluid and he won't be going anywhere any time soon - unless this peculiar song choice hurts him.
Syesha Mercado
1987/Stephanie Mills/"If I Were Your Woman"
I started my first job in radio in 1987 - it was an Adult/Top 40 station and I don't ever remember playing this song or that Sting diddy that Jason just performed. Okay, maybe I remember this one a little. I guess she sang it okay. It just didn't do much for me.
Chikezie Eze
1985/Luther Vandross/"If Only for One Night"
Chikezie delivers a solid performance but I'd like to see Chikezie sing like Chikezie and not necessarily like Luther. He didn't make it his own and that could hurt him. Randy seems to agree with me.
Brooke White
1983/Police/"Every Breath You Take"
Starts out rough so she starts over. I've never been able to learn all the words to this song. She's got those down pat but she seems a little flat on the chorus. It's hard to say how this will be received. Definitely not her best. Still, better than most ... and definitely prettier than most. Who else could make such a big mistake in the beginning and still be forgiven by the judges?
Michael Johns
1978/Queen/"We Are the Champions"
He does Queen very well. Not as nice as when he did "Bohemian Rhapsody," but still quite enjoyable. Finally, some good music for my ears tonight. Can I say he has a nice butt? Well, it is my blog reflecting no connection with anything but myself so ... NICE BUTT! Oh, he sang very well too!
Carly Smithson
1983/Bonnie Tyler/"Total Eclipse of the Heart"
BIG BIG SONG CHOICE ALERT! I remember the first time I ever heard this song and I proclaimed it would go to Number 1 in a big hurry. One of my many song predictions to come true. For Carly - EXCELLENT song choice. Randy didn't like it and therefore should be tested for drug use. I must agree with Paula that Carly could do no wrong. Why are they trying to push her out of the competition? I'm so giving all my votes to her and Michael Johns so far!
David Archuleta
1990/David Foster/"You're the Voice"
While it's not his best performance, David is totally feeling this song and looks like he's having a blast performing it. Not my kind of song, whatever song it is, but how can you not love Archuleta?
Kristy Lee Cook
1984/Lee Greenwood/"God Bless the USA"
Smart move going with a country song. But will she properly emote it? If it were the 4th of July, I'd be waving the flag. As it is, she misses a few notes and pitchiness. I have no idea how she will fare this week. Simon loves it and even comments on the smartness of the song choice - seeing as it this is "AMERICAN" Idol!
David Cook
1982/Michael Jackson/"Billie Jean"
He's singing some other's rendition of Michael Jackson's "Billie Jean." I'm not crazy about the version but I'm definitely crazy about David Cook. This dude has the vocals, dude, and like, dude, he stands a great chance of being in the Top 3 and potentially our next American Idol. Randy has proclaimed him the winner. Paula is so damned impressed that she stands to deliver her words of actual wisdom. Simon called it brave and amazing. Now we know why he got the "pimp" spot. Crap - now I have to vote for three people. I better get busy!
My picks for Bottom 3 tonight are: Ramiele, Syesha and Chikezie. Who is going home? Probably Kristy Lee - but she doesn't deserve it.
Kimberley Locke performs tomorrow night! Hooray!
Wednesday, March 19, 2008
Who Comprises the Touring Top Ten?
So, did you get online last Saturday morning for your tickets to the Carrie Underwood and Josh Turner concert April 30 at the Amarillo Civic Center? I did and I can’t wait! Hooray!
I have a speech to finish writing for tomorrow so I’ll spare you the useless details.
Who could we see on tour somewhere down the road? Let’s find out. There’s a comfy couch and three cold, metal stools. Those who make it get the couch and as you probably figured, the bottom three get the stools.
Brooke White – couch
Carly Smithson – stool – WTF???????????????
David Archuleta – couch
Michael Johns – couch
David Cook – couch
Kristy Lee Cook – stool – no surprise there
Jason Castro – couch
Ramielle Malubay – couch – how is she in the Top Ten and Carly is sitting in the Bottom Three? How am I supposed to write and memorize a speech under these conditions. People!!!???!!!
Syesha Mercado – couch
Amanda Overmyer and Chickezie Eze are now center stage – Chickezie is safe and Amanda is in the Bottom Three.
Between Kristy Lee, Carly and Amanda, one would imagine it’s Kristy Lee going home but then again, who would’ve thunk Carly – the best singer in this competition – would be in the Bottom Three – ever??? Okay, enough drama. Who is it???
Tonight, we say goodbye to … shit … Amanda. Forgive the language but tonight’s Bottom Three followed by the elimination is unfathomable. Too bad for Idol because while Amanda wasn’t one of my favorites, I thought she was good for the competition and would have been a great asset to the Idol tour. What a pity.
Well, I guess we’ll see you back here next week.
I have a speech to finish writing for tomorrow so I’ll spare you the useless details.
Who could we see on tour somewhere down the road? Let’s find out. There’s a comfy couch and three cold, metal stools. Those who make it get the couch and as you probably figured, the bottom three get the stools.
Brooke White – couch
Carly Smithson – stool – WTF???????????????
David Archuleta – couch
Michael Johns – couch
David Cook – couch
Kristy Lee Cook – stool – no surprise there
Jason Castro – couch
Ramielle Malubay – couch – how is she in the Top Ten and Carly is sitting in the Bottom Three? How am I supposed to write and memorize a speech under these conditions. People!!!???!!!
Syesha Mercado – couch
Amanda Overmyer and Chickezie Eze are now center stage – Chickezie is safe and Amanda is in the Bottom Three.
Between Kristy Lee, Carly and Amanda, one would imagine it’s Kristy Lee going home but then again, who would’ve thunk Carly – the best singer in this competition – would be in the Bottom Three – ever??? Okay, enough drama. Who is it???
Tonight, we say goodbye to … shit … Amanda. Forgive the language but tonight’s Bottom Three followed by the elimination is unfathomable. Too bad for Idol because while Amanda wasn’t one of my favorites, I thought she was good for the competition and would have been a great asset to the Idol tour. What a pity.
Well, I guess we’ll see you back here next week.
Tuesday, March 18, 2008
Musical Wallpaper
Ryan needs a new hairdo. Maybe some highlights again. Come to think of it, me too.
In its 7-year run, this is the first time American Idol has carried a theme over an extra week but I think most of us would agree the Beatles merit more time. Besides, Paul McCartney could use the extra royalty money to help recover (yeah, right) from this week's divorce settlement with a money hungry, attention mongering, lovely young woman who I'm sure entered into the marriage with nothing but love and good intentions. Oh wait, this is about American Idol ...
Amanda Overmyer
"Back in the USSR"
This song isn't even on my list of Beatles favorites so it's a little difficult to judge considering the fact that I don't like the song to begin with. I'm not feeling it. If I'm judging over the course of a two-week period, Amanda is losing my attention fast. Still, ya gotta love her spirit.
Kristy Lee Cook
"You Got to Hide Your Love Away"
This song does a much better job of showcasing Kristy Lee's voice in the opening lines. Unfortunately, she falls flat come time for the chorus. Sometimes, you forget how brilliantly written and sung these songs are until someone else gets their vocals on 'em. That said, Kristy, finishes strong but it won't be enough to save her this week. It doesn't help that Simon refers to her lack of performing talent as "musical wallpaper."
David Archuleta
"The Long and Winding Road"
It's not my favorite from Archuleta but still proves why so many girls - young and well-aged - love him so. Even Simon calls him "amazing."
Michael Johns
"A Day in the Life"
Excellent song choice for his voice. Randy disagrees. After hearing the judges' remarks, I think the mistake Michael made was in choosing a song that was impossible to communicate in 90 seconds.
Brooke White
"Here Comes the Sun"
It's not my favorite from Brooke as she tries to break out of her shell and work the stage a tad bit. Still, decent vocals. Pales in comparison to last week for me.
David Cook
"Day Tripper"
Staying true to his rock roots, David C. delivers a solid performance - but not his best. Despite that, probably the best of tonight so far.
Carly Smithson
"Blackbird"
I can't say I'm familiar with this song but one thing I can say is that Carly is flawless. Vocal perfection.
Jason Castro
"Michelle"
Hmm. Interesting song choice. It could even be considered safe - except for those tricky parts in French. This is the first time in a few weeks where I've caught a little nervousness is Jason's performance. Not bad - but no "wow" here either. Crowd loves it though.
Syesha Mercado
"Yesterday"
I didn't like the arrangement. I didn't like the delivery. I really didn't like that really, really, really bad, bad, bad note. She's at risk after that. Randy liked it. Paula liked it. Simon ... called it her best performance so far and thinks it will keep her in the competition. Well, what do I know. I guess we'll find out tomorrow night.
I didn't like the arrangement. I didn't like the delivery. I really didn't like that really, really, really bad, bad, bad note. She's at risk after that. Randy liked it. Paula liked it. Simon ... called it her best performance so far and thinks it will keep her in the competition. Well, what do I know. I guess we'll find out tomorrow night.
Chikezie Eze
"I've Just Seen a Face"
I've been pleasantly surprised by Chikezie's ability to interpret Beatles' music into his own vibe. I liked it.
Ramiele Malubay
"I Should Have Known Better"
Ramiele has a good voice but not for this. Very karaoke.
Who are you voting for? Who is going home? I'm voting for Carly definitely. My second favorite was David C. followed by Archuleta. Here's who I'm putting in the bottom 3: Amanda, Syesha and Ramiele ... oops, I forgot about Kristy. Either way, a girl will be going home tomorrow night. Of course, it was a bit bland from Jason tonight. Who knows what's going to happen?
Wednesday, March 12, 2008
29 Million Votes Later and ...
More than 29 million votes were cast after last night's two hours showcasing Season 7's Top 12 contenders. Tonight, one of them will be sent home. My prediction is for Ramiele.
Mr. Jim Carrey is a special guest tonight promoting some animated movie in which he apparently voices an elephant. Appropriately, he is dressed as such.
Right before introducing the Top 12's s Beatle medley, Ryan reveals that after all of the positive feedback from last night's Beatles' tribute, they are carrying the theme over to next week.
Crap ... there's a shot of Sanjaya and his hair. Will it ever go away?
After a recap, Ryan asks four of the 12 contestants to stand as he reveals their fates.
Carly is safe. Michael is safe. Jason is safe. Syesha is in the bottom three and is asked to perform her song - knowing full well she could be the one going home tonight.
Great Idol-casted Ford commercial.
Another four are asked to stand and ... Chickezie is safe. Amanda is safe. David Cook is safe. Kristy Lee Cook asks for her microphone so she can go ahead and get her song over with. Ryan still makes her go through the torture and then let's her sing. Crap, another shot of Sanjaya. Take me to The Pavillion now! I'm not surprised she's in the bottom three but she shouldn't be going home tonight. Who will join Kristy Lee and Syesha?
In a lame attempt to milk an hour's worth of segments between commercials, Ryan takes viewers' calls.
Now, David Foster and Katharine McPhee perform ... this is stupid and a waste of my time when I could be writing my Toastmasters' speech for tomorrow. Upon reading the last sentence, the much-neglected husband says I could be paying more attention to him. Time for a disgusting kissy break ...
Kissy
Kissy
Kissy
Well, that was as satisfying as a Snickers!
Back to the show. Ugh, McPhee is still singing a snorefest.
NEWS ALERT!!! I'm not going to tell you the commercial I just saw because I don't want anyone snatching up my seats!!!! BUT OH MY GOD!!!! IN AMARILLO!!! HOORAY!!! I ain't telling! But both men and women will be happy!!! Happy, happy happy!!! I'll break into my savings to go see this!!!
Okay ... I think I've got that out of my system.
CAN YOU BELIEVE IT! AN IDOL IN AMARILLO??? OH MY GOD!!!
More attention on Carrey and the movie plug. Isn't this supposed to be about the contestants???? Ugh!
Of the remaining four, it should be Ramiele.
Archuletta gets a chance to redeem himself next week because he is safe. Hopefully he won't forget his words ever again. Brooke the Beautiful is safe and I'd like to think the husband and I had something to do with that.
So, is it Ramiele or David Hernandez going home? YOU GOTTA BE KIDDING ME!!! RAMIELE IS SAFE????? What the felines??? (Yes, I censure myself!) So it's down to David H., Kristy Lee and Syesha.
The first one sent to safety (after the break) is ... Syesha. She's quickly followed by Kristy Lee and it's David Hernandez who is going home.
Next week, more Beatles ... and hopefully I can improve on my 0-1 record. Is Darci Rae out there? Please girl - ya gotta share your predictions - you're much better at that than me! It's time to go to bed folks!
Mr. Jim Carrey is a special guest tonight promoting some animated movie in which he apparently voices an elephant. Appropriately, he is dressed as such.
Right before introducing the Top 12's s Beatle medley, Ryan reveals that after all of the positive feedback from last night's Beatles' tribute, they are carrying the theme over to next week.
Crap ... there's a shot of Sanjaya and his hair. Will it ever go away?
After a recap, Ryan asks four of the 12 contestants to stand as he reveals their fates.
Carly is safe. Michael is safe. Jason is safe. Syesha is in the bottom three and is asked to perform her song - knowing full well she could be the one going home tonight.
Great Idol-casted Ford commercial.
Another four are asked to stand and ... Chickezie is safe. Amanda is safe. David Cook is safe. Kristy Lee Cook asks for her microphone so she can go ahead and get her song over with. Ryan still makes her go through the torture and then let's her sing. Crap, another shot of Sanjaya. Take me to The Pavillion now! I'm not surprised she's in the bottom three but she shouldn't be going home tonight. Who will join Kristy Lee and Syesha?
In a lame attempt to milk an hour's worth of segments between commercials, Ryan takes viewers' calls.
Now, David Foster and Katharine McPhee perform ... this is stupid and a waste of my time when I could be writing my Toastmasters' speech for tomorrow. Upon reading the last sentence, the much-neglected husband says I could be paying more attention to him. Time for a disgusting kissy break ...
Kissy
Kissy
Kissy
Well, that was as satisfying as a Snickers!
Back to the show. Ugh, McPhee is still singing a snorefest.
NEWS ALERT!!! I'm not going to tell you the commercial I just saw because I don't want anyone snatching up my seats!!!! BUT OH MY GOD!!!! IN AMARILLO!!! HOORAY!!! I ain't telling! But both men and women will be happy!!! Happy, happy happy!!! I'll break into my savings to go see this!!!
Okay ... I think I've got that out of my system.
CAN YOU BELIEVE IT! AN IDOL IN AMARILLO??? OH MY GOD!!!
More attention on Carrey and the movie plug. Isn't this supposed to be about the contestants???? Ugh!
Of the remaining four, it should be Ramiele.
Archuletta gets a chance to redeem himself next week because he is safe. Hopefully he won't forget his words ever again. Brooke the Beautiful is safe and I'd like to think the husband and I had something to do with that.
So, is it Ramiele or David Hernandez going home? YOU GOTTA BE KIDDING ME!!! RAMIELE IS SAFE????? What the felines??? (Yes, I censure myself!) So it's down to David H., Kristy Lee and Syesha.
The first one sent to safety (after the break) is ... Syesha. She's quickly followed by Kristy Lee and it's David Hernandez who is going home.
Next week, more Beatles ... and hopefully I can improve on my 0-1 record. Is Darci Rae out there? Please girl - ya gotta share your predictions - you're much better at that than me! It's time to go to bed folks!
Tuesday, March 11, 2008
Beatlemania – Idol Style
Tonight’s show kicks off with a lot of hoopla that has nothing to do with why I watch. Hooray for the new set, the blinding lights, the band’s new penthouse and the goofy "mosh pit" full of fans next to the judges. What I’m more excited to see is how our Top 12 fare on some of the best songs ever written, courtesy of the legendary Lennon-McCartney Songbook.
Syesha Mercado
"Got To Get You Into My Life"
Syesha shows off her lower register but it takes her off-pitch at first. Thankfully, she breathes a little soul into this typically pop song. She was pretty good for being the first fish in the sea, but as the husband notes, there is no "wow" factor in the whole package.
Chikezie Eze
"She’s a Woman"
Excellent song choice for Chikezie. It really shows a side of him we’ve never been treated to before. Yeah, he’s nervous, but he’s having a blast – as it should be! He’s proving that he deserves to be in the Top 12. I thoroughly enjoyed this performance! God, this is why I watch! Even Simon is smiling! Where’s Chikezie been hiding?
Ramiele Malubay
"In My Life"
She’s seems breathier than usual tonight but she’s does have a lovely and pleasant voice. Her interpretation of the song though does nothing to demonstrate what a beautiful and moving song it is. It also does nothing to showcase her vocal strength. She even ends on a sour note, to me. Randy seems to agree with me. As Simon sums it up, Ramiele is "better than that."
Jason Castro
"If I Fell"
Jason’s comfortably tucked behind his guitar as he strums along to the sweet lyrics of "If I Fell." He had a couple of bad notes, but it was so soothing that I don’t think I care. He’s precious.
Carly Smithson
"Come Together"
I’m 100 percent a Carly fan so she better not disappoint tonight! She looks totally comfortable on this beast of a stage. Her voice is great but she can do better than this – which is hard to believe – and that’s what I love about Carly. You never know what she’s going to bring to the table but you know you’ll leave satisfied.
David Cook
"Eleanor Rigby"
David C.’s voice is so incredibly different from anything else out there that I’m compelled to love it. He begins a little rough and has some pitch problems but once he gets into it, David C. delivers. I’m a fan. Simon calls it "brilliant."
Brooke White
"Let It Be"
Brooke takes on a big one – the Beatles last single. The only thing I don’t like is she didn’t take the high not on the "Be." That aside, she is the most loveliest young woman I’ve ever seen and I don’t mean the flawless skin, the wavy hair or her captivating smile. You can truly see Brooke’s soul shine and it shines through in every performance she delivers. The judges are happy, the audience has embraced her and it’s not 9 o’clock yet so I can’t start voting. Darn, darn, darn!!!
David Hernandez
"I Saw Her Standing There"
The band is fabulous. It’s a fun performance for David H. but it does nothing to say he’s the next "American Idol." We’ll see him singing show tunes on a cheap cruise in the near future … or I will be like so totally proven wrong. Based on the judges’ feedback, I’m not off base.
Amanda Overmyer
"You Can’t Do That"
Although it’s classic Amanda form, it almost sounds like Elvis doing the Beatles. Still, pretty amazing chops. That said, it really doesn’t do much for me but the crowd is lovin’ it. She’s like a female Gene Simmons.
Michael Johns
"Across the Universe"
This is the best and truest Michael’s voice has sounded in the last few weeks. It really puts his vocals in the spotlight ad I’m liking it. He definitely connects with the song, and with the audience. Randy and Simon rip him apart though and I’m left, oddly, agreeing with Paula’s critique that it was "brilliant."
Kristy Lee Cook
"Eight Days a Week"
In her vignette, Kristy Lee reveals she’ll be putting a country spin on a Beatles’ tune.
It’s a big risk but I think she pulls it off but will the voters buy her twangy rendition? It was different. Very different. I think people who live and breathe country will love it.
David Archuleta
"We Can Work It Out"
Have we saved the best for last? SHOCKER!!! Our sweet little cutie pie keeps forgetting his lyrics. Are viewers going to remember his genius performances from weeks passed or will they be unforgiving? Let’s see what the judges lay down. It didn’t work for Randy. Paula is forgiving. Simon says it like it is, telling David A. that it was his worst performance to date.
I have way too many favorites way too soon in the competition and tonight, I’m sad to say that Archuleta isn’t one of them. I still don’t pick him for going home. Tomorrow night I fear Ramiele will be sent packing. It’s hard to say who’s performance I loved the most though. I’m a huge Carly fan. David Cook is amazing. Michael Johns was flawless. But let’s face it. Brooke pulled off the vocals beautifully and didn’t miss a note on the keyboard. I better get busy and dial!
Syesha Mercado
"Got To Get You Into My Life"
Syesha shows off her lower register but it takes her off-pitch at first. Thankfully, she breathes a little soul into this typically pop song. She was pretty good for being the first fish in the sea, but as the husband notes, there is no "wow" factor in the whole package.
Chikezie Eze
"She’s a Woman"
Excellent song choice for Chikezie. It really shows a side of him we’ve never been treated to before. Yeah, he’s nervous, but he’s having a blast – as it should be! He’s proving that he deserves to be in the Top 12. I thoroughly enjoyed this performance! God, this is why I watch! Even Simon is smiling! Where’s Chikezie been hiding?
Ramiele Malubay
"In My Life"
She’s seems breathier than usual tonight but she’s does have a lovely and pleasant voice. Her interpretation of the song though does nothing to demonstrate what a beautiful and moving song it is. It also does nothing to showcase her vocal strength. She even ends on a sour note, to me. Randy seems to agree with me. As Simon sums it up, Ramiele is "better than that."
Jason Castro
"If I Fell"
Jason’s comfortably tucked behind his guitar as he strums along to the sweet lyrics of "If I Fell." He had a couple of bad notes, but it was so soothing that I don’t think I care. He’s precious.
Carly Smithson
"Come Together"
I’m 100 percent a Carly fan so she better not disappoint tonight! She looks totally comfortable on this beast of a stage. Her voice is great but she can do better than this – which is hard to believe – and that’s what I love about Carly. You never know what she’s going to bring to the table but you know you’ll leave satisfied.
David Cook
"Eleanor Rigby"
David C.’s voice is so incredibly different from anything else out there that I’m compelled to love it. He begins a little rough and has some pitch problems but once he gets into it, David C. delivers. I’m a fan. Simon calls it "brilliant."
Brooke White
"Let It Be"
Brooke takes on a big one – the Beatles last single. The only thing I don’t like is she didn’t take the high not on the "Be." That aside, she is the most loveliest young woman I’ve ever seen and I don’t mean the flawless skin, the wavy hair or her captivating smile. You can truly see Brooke’s soul shine and it shines through in every performance she delivers. The judges are happy, the audience has embraced her and it’s not 9 o’clock yet so I can’t start voting. Darn, darn, darn!!!
David Hernandez
"I Saw Her Standing There"
The band is fabulous. It’s a fun performance for David H. but it does nothing to say he’s the next "American Idol." We’ll see him singing show tunes on a cheap cruise in the near future … or I will be like so totally proven wrong. Based on the judges’ feedback, I’m not off base.
Amanda Overmyer
"You Can’t Do That"
Although it’s classic Amanda form, it almost sounds like Elvis doing the Beatles. Still, pretty amazing chops. That said, it really doesn’t do much for me but the crowd is lovin’ it. She’s like a female Gene Simmons.
Michael Johns
"Across the Universe"
This is the best and truest Michael’s voice has sounded in the last few weeks. It really puts his vocals in the spotlight ad I’m liking it. He definitely connects with the song, and with the audience. Randy and Simon rip him apart though and I’m left, oddly, agreeing with Paula’s critique that it was "brilliant."
Kristy Lee Cook
"Eight Days a Week"
In her vignette, Kristy Lee reveals she’ll be putting a country spin on a Beatles’ tune.
It’s a big risk but I think she pulls it off but will the voters buy her twangy rendition? It was different. Very different. I think people who live and breathe country will love it.
David Archuleta
"We Can Work It Out"
Have we saved the best for last? SHOCKER!!! Our sweet little cutie pie keeps forgetting his lyrics. Are viewers going to remember his genius performances from weeks passed or will they be unforgiving? Let’s see what the judges lay down. It didn’t work for Randy. Paula is forgiving. Simon says it like it is, telling David A. that it was his worst performance to date.
I have way too many favorites way too soon in the competition and tonight, I’m sad to say that Archuleta isn’t one of them. I still don’t pick him for going home. Tomorrow night I fear Ramiele will be sent packing. It’s hard to say who’s performance I loved the most though. I’m a huge Carly fan. David Cook is amazing. Michael Johns was flawless. But let’s face it. Brooke pulled off the vocals beautifully and didn’t miss a note on the keyboard. I better get busy and dial!
Thursday, March 6, 2008
Top 12 Decided
What kind of stupid 80s montage will our group of 16 youngsters subject us to tonight? Good news! It doesn’t look like there will be one. Thank goodness! Instead, we’re treated to a performance from last year’s American Idol Runner-Up Blake Lewis. Last year’s batch, with the exception of Melinda Doolittle and to a degree Blake, was a dismal bunch of losers. I’m liking this Blake ditty but the song would be more enjoyable without his trademark beat boxing. To recap, I predicted Danny Noriega and Luke Menard would be going home tonight for the guys. For the girls, Kady Malloy and Asia’h Epperson. So, here’s how it’s going down …
Safe
David Cook
David Archuleta
Jason Castro
Brooke White
Syesha Mercado
Gone
Kady Malloy – So far, I’m one for one on my predictions.
Safe
David Hernandez
Michael Johns
Gone
Luke Menard – Two for two.
Safe
Remiele Malubay
Carly Smithson
Amanda Overmyer
Kristy Lee Cook
Gone
Asia’h Epperson – Three for three. This has to be very emotional considering her dad passed away two days before she even began on her AI journey. If she would have sang last night the way she is right now, she may have still been in the competition.
So, it’s down to Danny Noriega and Chikezie Eze. Chikezie is ready to accept the worst news ever only to be told to take a seat. He’s safe and obviously flabbergasted. I’m not. He deserves to stick around and not so sadly, we say adios to my fourth correct prediction – BYE BYE GIRLY MAN!
Next week we should be treated to the vast repertoire of Beatles tunes for the first time in American Idol history. Hooray!!! Anything from that Sgt. Pepper’s album works for me!
Safe
David Cook
David Archuleta
Jason Castro
Brooke White
Syesha Mercado
Gone
Kady Malloy – So far, I’m one for one on my predictions.
Safe
David Hernandez
Michael Johns
Gone
Luke Menard – Two for two.
Safe
Remiele Malubay
Carly Smithson
Amanda Overmyer
Kristy Lee Cook
Gone
Asia’h Epperson – Three for three. This has to be very emotional considering her dad passed away two days before she even began on her AI journey. If she would have sang last night the way she is right now, she may have still been in the competition.
So, it’s down to Danny Noriega and Chikezie Eze. Chikezie is ready to accept the worst news ever only to be told to take a seat. He’s safe and obviously flabbergasted. I’m not. He deserves to stick around and not so sadly, we say adios to my fourth correct prediction – BYE BYE GIRLY MAN!
Next week we should be treated to the vast repertoire of Beatles tunes for the first time in American Idol history. Hooray!!! Anything from that Sgt. Pepper’s album works for me!
Wednesday, March 5, 2008
The Guys Were Better
I don’t know about you, but I’m still upset about Alaina’s untimely departure last week. It doesn’t make sense because it’s not like I know this girl. At this point in the competition, emotions have not been vested in her as a contestant. If you can explain, click the comment button below.
Enough boo-hooing though. Let’s hope the girls will make better song choices than the guys did last night in the decade in which I suffered through junior high school, had no boyfriends and barely made it through Math I and Spanish I to graduate junior college.
1. Asia’h Epperson, 19
Whitney Houston/"I Wanna Dance With Somebody"
I’m hearing something here and it’s not the sweet sound of Whitney Houston. Instead, it’s a girl whose nerves are grabbing hold of her voice because she doesn’t have the chops to pull it off. Randy and Paula heard something I did or they’re seriously doped up with the praise they’re giving her.
Queen/"I Want to Live Forever"
I lived and breathed the 80s so how did I miss this song? I haven’t even heard it on XM 80s on 8. I guess it was okay but I wasn’t moved – except maybe to scratch my head in song choice confusion.
Joan Jett & The Blackhearts/"I Hate Myself for Loving You"
As much as I love her style and the gruffy vocals, I’m afraid I could be growing tired of her singing the same type of songs the same way week after week. Some would say she found her niche whereas I would say she’s hit a rut. The husband seems to feel that she really doesn’t want to be there.
Cyndi Lauper/"I Drove All Night"
WOW!!! Not only do Carly’s eyes look amazing but this song choice demonstrates her ability to smash the competition. A thousand votes for Carly!!!
Journey/"Faithfully"
This was a great song choice for her twangy voice. Plus, she’s absolutely lovely. Very, very good.
6. Remiele Malubay, 20
Phil Collins/"Against All Odds"
I guess it was impossible to get through the 80s week without someone thinking they could sing this song. I can’t believe it, but this might be the best attempt at Phil’s work in all of Idol history.
Pat Benatar/"Love is a Battlefield"
When Ryan announced this would be Brooke’s song choice, I doubted her ability to pull it off. But with her personal approach to the song, she accomplishes it. However, I wish she would go outside her vocal comfort zone. That said, she knows who she is.
Whitney Houston/"Saving All My Love for You"
What would an 80s night be without multiple attempts at the incredible Whitney Houston repertoire? Syesha is much better at it though than Asia’h was. It was carbon copy but at least it was good.
This show is a great distraction from life’s daily horse manure. So, who is getting the big kiss-off tomorrow night? I don’t think any of the girls royally screwed it up but I’m going to take a chance and say it will be Kady Malloy and Asia’h Epperson … but I’ve been wrong about Kady before! Best of the night? Carly all the way!!!
Enough boo-hooing though. Let’s hope the girls will make better song choices than the guys did last night in the decade in which I suffered through junior high school, had no boyfriends and barely made it through Math I and Spanish I to graduate junior college.
1. Asia’h Epperson, 19
Whitney Houston/"I Wanna Dance With Somebody"
I’m hearing something here and it’s not the sweet sound of Whitney Houston. Instead, it’s a girl whose nerves are grabbing hold of her voice because she doesn’t have the chops to pull it off. Randy and Paula heard something I did or they’re seriously doped up with the praise they’re giving her.
2. Kady Malloy, 18
Queen/"I Want to Live Forever"
I lived and breathed the 80s so how did I miss this song? I haven’t even heard it on XM 80s on 8. I guess it was okay but I wasn’t moved – except maybe to scratch my head in song choice confusion.
3. Amanda Overmyer, 23
Joan Jett & The Blackhearts/"I Hate Myself for Loving You"
As much as I love her style and the gruffy vocals, I’m afraid I could be growing tired of her singing the same type of songs the same way week after week. Some would say she found her niche whereas I would say she’s hit a rut. The husband seems to feel that she really doesn’t want to be there.
4. Carly Smithson, 24
Cyndi Lauper/"I Drove All Night"
WOW!!! Not only do Carly’s eyes look amazing but this song choice demonstrates her ability to smash the competition. A thousand votes for Carly!!!
5. Kristy Lee Cook, 24
Journey/"Faithfully"
This was a great song choice for her twangy voice. Plus, she’s absolutely lovely. Very, very good.
6. Remiele Malubay, 20
Phil Collins/"Against All Odds"
I guess it was impossible to get through the 80s week without someone thinking they could sing this song. I can’t believe it, but this might be the best attempt at Phil’s work in all of Idol history.
7. Brooke White, 24
Pat Benatar/"Love is a Battlefield"
When Ryan announced this would be Brooke’s song choice, I doubted her ability to pull it off. But with her personal approach to the song, she accomplishes it. However, I wish she would go outside her vocal comfort zone. That said, she knows who she is.
8. Syesha Mercado, 21
Whitney Houston/"Saving All My Love for You"
What would an 80s night be without multiple attempts at the incredible Whitney Houston repertoire? Syesha is much better at it though than Asia’h was. It was carbon copy but at least it was good.
This show is a great distraction from life’s daily horse manure. So, who is getting the big kiss-off tomorrow night? I don’t think any of the girls royally screwed it up but I’m going to take a chance and say it will be Kady Malloy and Asia’h Epperson … but I’ve been wrong about Kady before! Best of the night? Carly all the way!!!
Tuesday, March 4, 2008
David C. is Cooking it Up on the Idol Stage Tonight
If the pattern holds, we’ll revisit my favorite decade this week on American Idol. But first, can we get past all the controversy? I knew from the very beginning that David Hernandez wasn’t being all that truthful when he said he sang in dinner theater or something like that. I remember telling my husband there was something "different" about this guy. Sure 'nuff … his work has been in nude stripping for a mostly male clientele. We’ll find out this week if that revelation will have any effect on David H.’s American Idol future.
Then there’s that other Fruit Loop – Danny Noriega. Google him if you don’t already know. It’s just too creepy to repeat.
Now that we’ve gotten past the drama, let’s get to the music.
Luke Menard, 29
Wham!/"Wake Me Up Before You Go Go"
When I started my car this morning, the first song I heard on my God-given XM satellite radio was Wham!’s "Wake Me Up Before You Go Go." I didn’t realize how good George Michael was until Luke Menard made it feel so … so … yucky. Simon called it "girlie." Oh, and it was bad too.
David Archuleta, 17
Phil Collins/"Another Day in Paradise"
It wasn’t David’s best performance but I was impressed that he picked a Phil Collins tune that wasn’t "Against All Odds." He started out at the piano, which amazed me, and with perfect timing he took the mike and came out in front of the audience. But what’s really important to note here is that I love him. I love him. I love him. I love him. I want to gobble him up.
Danny Noriega, 18
Soft Cell/"Tainted Love"
Yuck. Yuck. Yuck. He thinks he’s something and he is, I just don’t know what. And the judges are about to make me puke out of my eyeballs until Simon speaks reason and says it best: "Absolutely useless."
David Hernandez, 24
Celine Dion/"It’s All Coming Back to Me Now."
Surprisingly much better than I expected. He didn’t hold the notes as long as Celine does but, still, despite a few pitch problems, it was enjoyable.
Michael Johns, 29
Simple Minds/"Don’t You Forget About Me"
I’m not sure this was a good song choice for his voice. It’s not bad … but it doesn’t make me want to undress him either. My God, will someone stuff a sock in Paula’s mouth? Now???!!!
David Cook, 25
Lionel Richie/"Hello"
One thing I’ve loved about David Cook is his amazing ability to take old songs and make them new again. It took me a minute to realize I was listening to a Lionel Richie tune. I remember the first time I heard this song I told my parents it was going to Number 1 on Billboard and, of course, it did. I have no doubt that if David Cook released his rendition today, it would go straight to Number 1 too. It’s the best performance of the night so far, to me – even better than Archuleta – because he really makes this song his own. Nice. Very, very nice. I would even say "amazing." Let’s make that AMAZING!!!
Jason Castro, 20
Leonard Cohen/"Hallelujah"
Another amazing voice. I could like so totally see Jason producing a modern-day folk album.
Chikezie Eze, 22
Luther Vandross/"All the Woman I Need"
It was a good performance for him. I think it was enough to keep him in the competition one more week.
Here’s who I predict should go home Thursday night: PAULA ABDUL. Seriously, though, I’d like to see Danny Noriega and Luke Menard to be shown the exit. But for safety’s sake, perhaps they also should make sure Michael Johns is aware of the way out too. Not his best. But … he’s still hot. The husband seems to think Chikezie may not have it so "easy" this week.
What say you? Click on the comment button below!
Then there’s that other Fruit Loop – Danny Noriega. Google him if you don’t already know. It’s just too creepy to repeat.
Now that we’ve gotten past the drama, let’s get to the music.
Luke Menard, 29
Wham!/"Wake Me Up Before You Go Go"
When I started my car this morning, the first song I heard on my God-given XM satellite radio was Wham!’s "Wake Me Up Before You Go Go." I didn’t realize how good George Michael was until Luke Menard made it feel so … so … yucky. Simon called it "girlie." Oh, and it was bad too.
David Archuleta, 17
Phil Collins/"Another Day in Paradise"
It wasn’t David’s best performance but I was impressed that he picked a Phil Collins tune that wasn’t "Against All Odds." He started out at the piano, which amazed me, and with perfect timing he took the mike and came out in front of the audience. But what’s really important to note here is that I love him. I love him. I love him. I love him. I want to gobble him up.
Danny Noriega, 18
Soft Cell/"Tainted Love"
Yuck. Yuck. Yuck. He thinks he’s something and he is, I just don’t know what. And the judges are about to make me puke out of my eyeballs until Simon speaks reason and says it best: "Absolutely useless."
David Hernandez, 24
Celine Dion/"It’s All Coming Back to Me Now."
Surprisingly much better than I expected. He didn’t hold the notes as long as Celine does but, still, despite a few pitch problems, it was enjoyable.
Michael Johns, 29
Simple Minds/"Don’t You Forget About Me"
I’m not sure this was a good song choice for his voice. It’s not bad … but it doesn’t make me want to undress him either. My God, will someone stuff a sock in Paula’s mouth? Now???!!!
David Cook, 25
Lionel Richie/"Hello"
One thing I’ve loved about David Cook is his amazing ability to take old songs and make them new again. It took me a minute to realize I was listening to a Lionel Richie tune. I remember the first time I heard this song I told my parents it was going to Number 1 on Billboard and, of course, it did. I have no doubt that if David Cook released his rendition today, it would go straight to Number 1 too. It’s the best performance of the night so far, to me – even better than Archuleta – because he really makes this song his own. Nice. Very, very nice. I would even say "amazing." Let’s make that AMAZING!!!
Jason Castro, 20
Leonard Cohen/"Hallelujah"
Another amazing voice. I could like so totally see Jason producing a modern-day folk album.
Chikezie Eze, 22
Luther Vandross/"All the Woman I Need"
It was a good performance for him. I think it was enough to keep him in the competition one more week.
Here’s who I predict should go home Thursday night: PAULA ABDUL. Seriously, though, I’d like to see Danny Noriega and Luke Menard to be shown the exit. But for safety’s sake, perhaps they also should make sure Michael Johns is aware of the way out too. Not his best. But … he’s still hot. The husband seems to think Chikezie may not have it so "easy" this week.
What say you? Click on the comment button below!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)